I’ve decided to back up a bit and explain how I decided that Mike would make a good working dog.
There’s a lot of advice out there on how to evaluate a puppy. Like any advice, take and use what feels comfortable to you. Some folk are believers of the Alpha Leader and Pack theories. Others lean more toward the Operant Conditioning theories. Some advice is given by folks who know what they are talking about. Others are compilations.
As I’ve mentioned before, I went to King, NC to meet with the folks of Foxdale Independent Rescue. They had a 4-5mos old pup named Happy that I was interested in meeting. Before I went, I did a lot of research. I Googled: temperament test, puppy temperament, and puppy assessment. I settled on a modified version of the Volhard Puppy Aptitude test (links below). Keep in mind as you search that there actually is a Temperament Test (a big step above the Canine Good Citizen test). You may want to read some about that, but for puppy evaluation, you want to look for puppy specific temperament stuff.
There was too much for me to write down, so I took screen shots. This also allowed me to view the information off-line in the car on the way there. There were a few basic things I would check for first then move on or stop based on the results.
Social Attraction: call the puppy to you by clapping, making happy noises, etc. It should come to you with joy and glee. But watch for biting and/or chewing on your hands. Watch for tail being down (it should be up).
Elevation Dominance: bend over the puppy, put your hands under its belly and lift it so the back feet are off the floor. This test is to see how the puppy reacts to something where it has no control on the situation. You want the pup to wiggle a little (perfectly normal to want control!) but then settle down and wait for you to do something else.
Social Dominance: sit or crouch next to the puppy. Stroke from head to almost the butt slowly several times. What you are doing, in essence, is telling the pup (in dog language) that you are socially dominant than it is. You want that pup to react calmly, either by playing with you or by leaning into the petting. Licking is fine. Growling or biting is not.
Roll Over/Restraint: get the pup to lay down and put your hand on it so it cannot get up. This is akin to the Elevation Dominance test but is more in the dog language. Wiggling is fine, but you want the dog to settle down and accept the situation. While you are keeping it there, you can talk to it, pet him, etc. Note: this is NOT the “dominance roll”. This is just keeping the dog in one place, laying down, for 30 seconds.
Happy, the pup we went to see, did not pass the Elevation test and probably did not pass the Social Dominance Test. I couldn’t get him into the Restraint position. He was middling to the Social Attraction test. But Mike and Pokey (Mike’s sibling) did great. Pokey was slower, seemed less concerned about everything. Later he was more active. I think he was either just waking up or needed a nap. From what I understood of what I was looking for, Happy would not have made a good working dog. As a pet, he would be good for someone who understood the potential problems and was strong enough to take him on. It is quite possible that outside that environment (he’d been with them a while), he may settle down and be less domineering. In our house, with the critters we have, a domineering pup would not have worked.
After realizing this, I decided to continue the testing on Mike and Pokey.
Retrieving: take a crumpled up bit of paper and toss it several feet away from the pup. A “natural retriever” will chase after it and pick it up. For a pet dog, this isn’t as important unless you want a dog to play fetch with you. If tossing a slobbery tennis ball is not something you are interested in, then this test isn’t as important for a pet dog although some folks believe it is an indicator of training interest.
Touch Sensitivity: pinch the skin/webbing between two of the pup’s toes. Start out light and slowly increase the pressure until you get a reaction. This tests how the pup responds to uncomfortable touching. Licking your hand is fine as is whining. But you do not want a pup who bites, yelps, or doesn’t react at all.
Sound Sensitivity: while the pup is looking in the opposite direction, make a loud noise such as clapping, dropping something, etc. This is also a basic test for deafness. The pup should react to the noise, certainly, but how it reacts is important. Bark aggressively? Bark in response? Jumps 15 feet in the opposite direction?
Mike and Pokey both chased and picked up anything I threw. Both mouthed and carried metal objects. Both were appropriate with the Touch and Sound sensitivity tests.
Now came the harder part. Observing the pups while they interacted with each other and the various stuff going on around them. How were they with the bigger dogs? The smaller ones? Do they share toys or hoard them? Do they play with each other or by themselves? When something new happens, how do they react? This is where Mike began to stand out from the others. When a noise from the other room startled everyone and started them barking, all but Mike charged the door. He sat back and watched first, then joined in. Happy chewed through the doorbell cord and the husband of the woman came in to cut it and put it away. All the others ran to him and got in his way while Mike sat back for a while, watching, then went to steal a bit of the wire. For me, it was this watchfulness, this observing his surroundings, that made me decide to adopt him. Others might have seen his behavior as being afraid or overly cautious, perhaps even too independent. That’s not how I saw it, though, because it’s a trait Mike and I share. Someone who was more active and go-get-em might have liked Happy or Pokey (once he woke up) better.
And this is why the Thirty Day Trial Period is important. That watchful pup might get home and turn into a charging demon. Or that go-get-em pup might slow down and decide chewing on the bedpost is more fun than chasing a ball. A good example of this is my Mom’s dog, Andee (who recently crossed the Rainbow Bridge). When they went to the pet store, the other pups were up at the wire, barking, jumping, hyper. Mom held several different pups and they were all wiggly, licking monsters. But over in the corner of the pen was Andee, sleeping with his back to the ruckus. Mom asked to hold him and he lay in her arms, ever so quiet and calm. She was able to put him on his back and he just laid there. Now fast forward. Andee grew up to be a practically non-stop maniac. Hyper, jumping, scratching legs – a complete opposite of what he was that day. (note: I’d not ever get a dog that was that quiet anyway since such behavior also indicates possible illness) By implementing the Thirty Day Trial Period, you acknowledge that things are going to change. Behaviors that were cute at the shelter or on adoption day may grow to be obnoxious habits. The pup becomes comfortable with itself and its new family. It also wants to push the boundaries (what child/teen doesn’t?).
Mike’s 30 days ended on Dec. 30th. I thought long and hard about how he had changed, how he had progressed, and how he stood on the potential to be a working dog. I looked at my notes from the day I first met him and remembered how he was that day. I compared that pup to the pup he is now. Mike will be a great Service Dog. He likes picking things up, carrying them around. He is responding well to clicker training. He is fitting in well with our pack.
No matter what method you use, research like mad before you even go see the first pup.
Research the breed(s) you are interested in. Know what you are getting yourself into. Is the breed suited for your lifestyle? Even if a mixed breed, some of the genetic ancestry will show through so research each breed that went into your potential new friend.
Then there’s the cost. Go to a pet supply store, take a pad of paper and a pen. Go around the store and write down the price of everything you and your pup would need. Crate, pad for the crate, leash, collar and/or harness, food bowl, water bowl, food (read the side of the bags to determine how much food your pup will eat), treats, toys, dog gate, brush, nail clippers, etc. Call the vet you will be using and ask for their prices on Wellness checks, spay/neuter, microchipping (usually around $50), puppy vaccines, etc. What about grooming? When I looked into getting a Standard Poodle, I found out that the regular grooming they require can cost as much as $60 every other month. Now take a look at that price list. Can you afford this pup? Can you afford to feed it as it grows?
Where will you get it? Breeder? Be prepared for high prices and, in some cases, snobbery. Rescue group? Be prepared for the Inquisition. In both cases, you will have to sign a contract. Know what the breeder or rescue group has in their contract before you even go look.
Looking for a Service Dog? Figure out what you want the dog to do. Do you need a large dog for brace work? Or will a smaller dog do? Is retrieving high on your list or do you need one to alert you to sounds? Can you clean up after a pup or do you need to get an adult?
Looking for a pet? Why do you want a dog? Why do you want a puppy? Is your lifestyle adaptable to the needs of a poop and pee machine? Is your house puppy proof? (sometimes I think no house can ever be 100% puppy proof)
Think about it. You’re considering bringing home something that could potentially live 16 or more years (our Casey is 15 and still going strong). Something that will need care, love, attention every day, several times a day. Pets are not disposable like electronics and treadmills. You can’t put it out on the curb for trash pick-up. You can’t (or shouldn’t) sell it in a yard sale.
**
Below are the main sources I used:
Assessing Shelter Dogs and Temperament Testing
Volhard Puppy Aptitude Test
Temperament Testing Puppies
American Temperament Test Society
International Association of Assistance Dog Partners – “Finding Mr. Right” articles
Dr. P’s Library – Puppies